UF ushers in a new age of engineering with a novel technology for 3-D printing the softest objects
By Cindy Spence

A dozen or so polymer jellyfish float in an aquarium in Tommy Angelini’s engineering lab, not alive but freaks of nature nonetheless, about to rock the world.

Just months ago, these jellyfish could not have existed; there was no way to make something so soft. That changed in 2014. Angelini was exploring ways to create fragile arrays of cells when he realized the contraption he had cobbled together not only did what he wanted it to do, but much, much, much more.

As experiments piled up — let’s try this, what if we try that — the contraption met every challenge, and doors long closed to scientific inquiry sprang open.

A new age of engineering, the Age of Soft Matter, had arrived.

As Angelini worked, he updated colleague and mentor Greg Sawyer on the eerily soft objects coming out of his lab. Sawyer issued a challenge.

“As engineers, you look at a jellyfish, and you say, that’s utterly impossible, how on earth could we manufacture that thing,” says Sawyer. “You want to make something? Make a jellyfish.”

Angelini did, and Sawyer says, “Now, let’s cross that off the impossible list, and get started.”

As a symbol of a new age and an engineering revolution that will change medicine and manufacturing, the no-longer-impossible jellyfish is perfect. If you can make a jellyfish, think what else you can make: cells, tissues, organs, tumors.


Before the jellyfish, there was a grant. Angelini had won a National Science Foundation Early Career Development Award, NSF’s most prestigious award for promising junior faculty, with a proposal to use the $500,000 to explore cell mechanics. To do that, he needed arrays of cells not confined to a petri dish. He needed cells in three dimensions.

“I wanted to study the basic physics of collective cell behavior,” Angelini says. “What do cells do spontaneously when driven by their own internal machinery?”

Tommy Angelini uses his lab’s refrigerator for quick calculations.

Angelini hired doctoral student Tapomoy Bhattacharjee and drew on assistance that ranged from a high school student working on a science fair project to Sawyer, a world-renowned tribologist and the Ebaugh professor in the Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering. Angelini bought a see-through laminar cabinet commonly used by geneticists because it had a way to filter air. He procured a fine-tipped nozzle like those used in 3-D printers. All he needed was a way to hold the printed cells in place; in other words, something that did not exist.

In traditional 3-D printing, the nozzle deposits liquid on a platform, and it hardens layer by layer until an object takes shape. That method would not work with something as squishy as a cell, which could not harden and would not be supported in air.

Angelini needed a specialized material, one soft enough to allow the most fragile object to take shape, but strong enough to hold it in place, so it could be studied and manipulated. The substance had to be neutral, neither contaminating nor augmenting the object it cradled, and it had to be soluble so it would rinse off, leaving no trace. It was a tall order, but Angelini figured a granular gel medium might work.

You know it as hand sanitizer.

The granular gel medium is the same as hand sanitizer without fragrance or alcohol. It straddles the solid-fluid states that Angelini needed to both hold a fragile object and later release it because the substance is 99.8 percent water. The other 0.2 percent is a polymer. As the nozzle passes through, the gel heals in its wake, leaving no sign of disturbance other than the soft, printed object, visible through the clear gel.

The intended goal — studying cells in 3-D — had an unintended, but groundbreaking, consequence — the invention of 3-D printing of soft matter.

As word spread across campus, the kneejerk reaction was, “No, that isn’t possible.” As chemists, biologists, neurologists, doctors and engineers trooped through Angelini’s laboratory, Bhattacharjee demonstrated, printing jellyfish after jellyfish, filling an aquarium with polymer creatures.

“We showed them, ‘This is the science, this is how it works,’” Bhattacharjee says. “It’s fun for a physicist, it’s fun for a biologist.”

Disbelief, Sawyer says, quickly turned to, “Wow, this is really cool!” Seconds later, wheels turning, that became, “What can I do with it?”

Sawyer and Angelini had suggestions.


In 2015, the American Cancer Society estimates 1,658,370 cases of cancer will be diagnosed in the United States; 589,430 cancer patients will die. By 2020, treating cancer will cost the U.S. over $200 billion a year.

Perhaps more staggering than the statistics is cancer’s reach. Every family has a cancer story, and that makes cancer a grand challenge for medicine.

Greg Sawyer examines a small-scale, soft matter model of a brain.

For Sawyer, it’s a personal challenge as well.

In 2013, Sawyer was diagnosed with stage IV metastatic melanoma. At first he felt helpless but, being an engineer, he did his homework. He joined a new immune therapy clinical trial, had a trio of painful operations and months of intense radiation to fight the disease. When Angelini printed the jellyfish a year later, the intersection with cancer was clear.

When the College of Medicine’s Celebration of Research rolled around, they browsed the posters at the O’Connell Center to see if they could find a collaborator. They ran into cancer researcher Steve Ghivizzani.

“I listened to them talk about this new technology, and I thought, ‘That’s just crazy.’ Greg says, ‘Just think about it: If you had the ability to position cellular things in space without restrictions, what could you use it for?’”

Ghivizzani did think about it and emailed Sawyer that night. He was in.

Cancer has been a thorny research subject because it is a chameleon. A cancer cell in one person doesn’t behave like a cancer cell in another, even if the cancers are the same. Even more confounding, each tumor is heterogeneous. On its exterior, it might be gorging on nutrients and replicating rapidly. Deep inside, it may be almost starving, but still alive, waiting for nutrients before growing. With thousands of cancer cells in each tumor, figuring out how the cells interact will be a key to future cancer treatment.

Ghivizzani says a tool that could allow cancer research to take not one step, but possibly many giant steps, got him excited.

“Innovations in science can sometimes be subtle,” Ghivizzani says. “This rocks.”

Cancer researchers have been stuck for years with two models, the petri dish and the mouse.

Cancer cells are easy to grow in a petri dish. But the biology of a cell growing in a dish is different from the biology of a cell growing in a body. In the body, cancer cells compete with other cells for nutrients, exhibiting aggression, or malignancy. In a petri dish, without competition, they adapt to their environment and often lose the malignancy a researcher wants to study. Ghivizzani says about two-thirds of the genes expressed in a tumor in the body are expressed in opposite ways in a petri dish.

The other model is the mouse, but that, too, has limits. Many cancers don’t grow in mice, prostate cancer, for instance. Most mice used for cancer research also have been genetically engineered to suppress their immune system, so immune therapies cannot be studied. Cancer grows slowly in mice, if at all, and sometimes the patients succumb before the mice can be tested. To see inside the mouse, you have to sacrifice the animal and further study of the tumor.

What is needed is a three-dimensional model between a petri dish and a mouse: 3-D soft matter printing of cancer cells.

The goal is to harvest a patient’s cancer cells, print them into the granular gel, and allow them to grow. In theory, unlimited samples could be grown and an unlimited number of therapies tried. Researchers couldn’t use 10,000 mice at once, but they could grow 10,000 samples and try different approaches. From immune therapies to various drugs, all the tests could take place at once, saving critical time for the patient.

“We can use this system to learn a lot more a lot faster than we have been able to do,” Ghivizzani says. “Can you take each patient, print replicas of their tumor and then try different therapies? That’s where we want to go.”

Ghivizzani says the ability to collaborate with engineers on cancer research is key to reaching that goal. Working with Sawyer and Angelini one afternoon during a test, it looked like they would not be able to print fast enough to continue working the next day.

“Greg sat down and did the math, and they built another machine. By the next morning, they had it reconfigured to work the way we needed it to function,” Ghivizzani says. “Their ability to solve those kinds of technical problems that are not biologic . . . without that, we won’t get where we want to go.”

Sawyer, who feels the urgency of his fellow cancer patients every 100 days when he visits his doctors, says engineers are perfect partners for cancer research. By January, he says, UF engineers will equip a lab at the College of Medicine with engineering tools for new research.

“At first, cancer seemed far from engineering. But look at it; it’s a dynamic system, far from equilibrium, and maybe that’s not so strange to engineers. This is tumor engineering. Give us six months, and we can really help from an engineering standpoint.

“Ten years from now, I think this will be the way researchers work with patients’ cancers,” Sawyer says.


A new age of engineering creates a lot of work, and Sawyer and Angelini were eager to share the cool, new science. Department Chair David Hahn agreed to a Soft Matter Engineering Research Group, and the scientists who witnessed the first jellyfish demonstrations signed on. Today, there are 28 collaborators, including two Sawyer protégés at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign and Florida International University.

“Tommy made that breakthrough, printing in the granular gel, that was the quantum step forward,” Hahn says. “Now there’s a thousand things to do on top of that with the subtleties of the materials, applications, the science behind it, understanding how these materials function. It’s huge.”

Teams of engineers and doctors will tackle four areas: mechanics and failure theories of soft matter; soft matter manufacturing; transport of materials through soft matter; and soft matter for medicine.

The objects printed in the lab are orders of magnitude softer than any man-made object. Angelini says he doesn’t know of a lower limit to the mechanical integrity of the objects the lab can make, and Hahn says new mechanics and failure theories will be needed; what works for titanium will not work for cells and polymers a million times softer.

“In simple terms, a hundred-plus years that we’ve built a foundation on in traditional mechanics is largely off the table with soft matter,” Hahn says. “It really is a whole new frontier of engineering.”

Floating jellyfish

Angelini’s lab did informal tests. One early jellyfish was placed in a jar and examined weekly. It held up just fine until, at the seven-month mark, it was knocked off a shelf. On impulse, Angelini tossed a container of polymer jellyfish in his backpack to travel to a conference in Germany. They survived, so he sent them by FedEx to a colleague in Cleveland and had them shipped back. The jellyfish were no worse for wear.

Now it’s time for science to back up — or disprove — the anecdotes.

Sawyer, the go-to guy for expertise on friction and wear in mechanics and materials, says what engineering has lacked from the Stone Age to the Plastics Age and beyond is softness; soft materials have always confounded engineers.

“What is soft matter? Actually, it’s everything; it’s most of the human body. The hard matter is the weird stuff. We’ve worked with it since the Stone Age because we knew the rules,” Sawyer says. “Now, we’ve entered the Soft Matter Age.”

Engineering Professor Kevin Jones, who views materials science through a broad lens that includes anthropology, the classics, humanities and history, is creating a soft matter module for an interdisciplinary course he coordinates, “The Impact of Materials on Society.” When he wrote the course flyer, one of the teasers was, “What future materials innovations will revolutionize your world?”

“I didn’t realize that at that very moment, one of those revolutions was taking place across campus,” Jones says.

That there is no textbook for this field that didn’t exist six months ago is an opportunity, not a problem, Jones and Hahn agree.

“This has a huge wow factor. Students who thought of engineering as cars and gears, can see that mechanical engineering can be about tissue scaffolds and artificial organs and other cool stuff,” Hahn says. “The jellyfish, it’s a vehicle for excitement.”


No one is waiting for theories. Across campus, scientists are making soft materials at such a pace that six patents are pending on a technology not yet a year old.

“We had no way to make materials so soft in the past and no reason to study it. Why study something so soft and gooey you couldn’t use it for anything?” Jones says. “The minute you can engineer something out of it, that changes everything.”

The lead in manufacturing is Curtis Taylor, assistant professor of mechanical and aerospace engineering. Already, Taylor is close to solving one of the first questions raised by the new technology: Is it possible to print efficiently with more than one material? Early experiments involved printing with a single material, in most cases polymers or cells. What if you wanted to print an object with different textures at different layers — a phantom brain, for instance, with a tumor under the surface?

Taylor and a team of students tackled that problem. They came up with an acrylic tube with four ports, one for the granular gel medium and three for other materials. To avoid the need for a valve to shut off one port so another can open, they came up with an ingenious solution: use the granular gel, which easily transitions from fluid to solid, as a plug.

The device is the size of a piece of bubblegum and would cost just $2. To make cellular or sterile materials implanted in humans the device is disposable, and although the prototype is acrylic, biodegradable materials work, too. As a manufacturing innovation, it looks simple, but it’s a workhorse.

“This little device replaces four nozzles, four pumps, four different needles, four different mechanisms for putting the needles into the gel,” Taylor says.

Also in the works are larger machines for larger objects and automation with robotic arms that can build from any angle. Questions remain, including the sequence of printing — inside out or outside in — and how fast it is possible to print with precision. To answer them, Taylor is actively recruiting. “I need a student,” he says, “I need a band of students.”

The printed soft materials can mimic the softness of human body parts, like the brain, and that opens new avenues for medical education, says neurosurgery professor Frank Bova.

A prototype of a hollow, flexible tube that represents on-demand, patient-specific medical devices.

By manufacturing artificial brains and other phantom organs that students can practice on, medical education could take a leap forward, Bova says. Models of bones and cartilage have been readily available for practice, but not soft organs.

One problem with teaching medical students is having the right case at the right time. Often, complicated cases come in when a student is learning more basic methods. Bova envisions a library of phantoms, easily printed as needed, giving students cases appropriate for their skill level as their skills grow.

Other phantoms could benefit personalized medicine. A patient’s brain could be scanned and printed with its own personal architecture — tumors, blood vessels, neurons — allowing the surgeon to rehearse before operating on the patient.

Angelini says, “Can you imagine, hearing your surgeon say, ‘Good morning, I’ve practiced this surgery on your brain five times already. You’re in good hands.”

Some colleagues are stunned by the simplicity of his idea and how easily it adapts to different uses. But that’s engineering, Angelini says, the best solutions are simple and elegant.

“Every time we thought of a new thing to do with this technology, it turned out to be really amazing. Every time we thought of a new task or a new test, the material we were using turned out to have a fantastic solution,” Angelini says.

The jellyfish — the impossible jellyfish — was almost too easy, but the road ahead holds challenges.

“I think we will help people,” Sawyer says. “This may not help me, but it will help somebody.

“We’re engineers, and engineers, regardless of what it is, feel there’s got to be something we can do to effect change. There’s a certain amount of pleasure you get from just being in the fight. I like that.”

Related Website:

This article was originally featured in the Fall 2015 issue of Explore Magazine.

成版人抖音app污下载安装 樱桃成版人 91香蕉app污下载安装 大象视频app污下载安装 草榴直播app污下载安装 鸭脖视频成版人 野花视频app下载免费 盘他app污下载安装 欢喜视频app污下载安装 后宫app下载免费 小奶狗app污下载安装 蜜橙视频app下载免费 暗夜直播app下载免费 圣女直播成版人 小米粒直播app下载免费 草榴直播app下载免费 蜜桃直播成版人 朵朵直播app下载免费 小猪视频app污下载安装 JAV名优馆成版人 黄鱼视频app污下载安装 蜜柚直播app下载免费 幸福宝成版人 蜜桃直播app污下载安装 AVnight成版人 盘他直播app下载免费 荔枝app污下载安装 快喵app下载免费 小喵直播app下载免费 探探直播成版人 米老鼠直播app下载免费 逗趣直播成版人 花心直播成版人 荔枝app下载免费 猛虎视频app污下载安装 花狐狸直播成版人 花椒直播成版人 花姬app下载免费 s8视频app下载免费 梦幻直播app污下载安装 云上花直播app下载免费 千层浪直播成版人 夜遇直播号成版人 宅男之家成版人 小仙女app污下载安装 繁花直播app下载免费 火爆社区成版人 盘她直播app污下载安装 小狐仙视频成版人 月夜直播成版人 红楼直播app下载免费 男人本色西瓜视频app下载免费 青青草成版人 微杏成版人 蚪音app下载免费 泡芙短视频成版人 柠檬视频成版人 ML聚合成版人 盘她成版人 趣播app下载免费 番茄直播app污下载安装 光棍影院app下载免费 月夜直播app污下载安装 猛虎视频app污下载安装 啪嗒视频成版人 享受直播app下载免费 大菠萝app污下载安装 硬汉视频app污下载安装 BB直播app污下载安装 快猫app下载免费 小小影视成版人 小喵直播app污下载安装 水晶直播app下载免费 Avboboapp污下载安装 美梦视频app污下载安装 麻豆传媒视频app下载免费 盘她app下载免费 JOJO直播app污下载安装 丝瓜成版人 冈本app下载免费 恋人直播成版人 蓝精灵直播成版人 佳丽直播成版人 恋夜秀场成版人 BB直播app下载免费 朵朵直播app下载免费 杏吧直播app下载免费 蝶恋花成版人 午夜直播app下载免费 初见直播app下载免费 黄瓜视频人成版人 91视频app污下载安装 宅男之家app下载免费 探探直播成版人 花姬直播成版人 ML聚合app下载免费 丝瓜视频污app下载免费 番茄社区app下载免费 夜魅直播app污下载安装 陌秀直播app下载免费 草莓直播app污下载安装 妖妖直播成版人 花心社区app污下载安装 茄子直播app污下载安装 享爱app污下载安装 小草视频app污下载安装 菠萝蜜成版人 成版人快手成版人 盘他直播成版人 月色直播app污下载安装 蜜柚直播app污下载安装 小奶猫成版人 后宫app污下载安装 小天仙直播app污下载安装 彩云直播app下载免费 考拉直播成版人 含羞草视频app下载免费 佳丽直播成版人 麻豆传媒直播app污下载安装 草榴直播成版人 小优app下载免费 夏娃直播app下载免费 lutubeapp下载免费 小优app污下载安装 蜜柚app下载免费 迷雾直播app污下载安装 午夜直播间app下载免费 后宫视频成版人 水晶直播app污下载安装 望月直播app下载免费 云雨直播app污下载安装 小花螺直播app污下载安装 小蝌蚪视频app下载免费 奶茶视频app污下载安装 咪咪直播app下载免费 合欢视频app污下载安装 火爆社区app污下载安装 成版人抖音成版人 繁花直播app污下载安装 香蕉app下载免费 JOJO直播成版人 草鱼app下载免费 笔芯直播app污下载安装 棉花糖直播app污下载安装 成版人抖音富二代app下载免费 直播盒子app污下载安装 花秀神器成版人 麻豆视频成版人 茄子视频成版人 迷雾直播成版人 丝瓜视频成版人 笔芯直播成版人 花心社区成版人 云上花成版人 花心社区app下载免费 千层浪app污下载安装 欢喜视频app污下载安装 猫咪视频成版人 豆奶视频app污下载安装 月色直播app下载免费 兔子直播app下载免费 蜜橙视频app下载免费 兔子直播app污下载安装 可乐视频app污下载安装 69热app污下载安装 月光直播app污下载安装 富二代成版人 秀色直播app下载免费 盘他app污下载安装 探花直播app污下载安装 嘿嘿连载app下载免费 91香蕉视频app污下载安装 午夜直播间app污下载安装 烟花巷app污下载安装 柠檬视频成版人 AVBOBOapp污下载安装 丝瓜app下载免费 iAVBOBOapp污下载安装 菠萝蜜视频成版人 爱爱视频app下载免费 猛虎直播app下载免费 福利直播成版人 千层浪app下载免费 棉花糖直播app污下载安装 6房间视频直播成版人 橘子直播app污下载安装 小蝌蚪成版人 小蝌蚪视频成版人 d2天堂app污下载安装 免费黃色直播app污下载安装 酷咪直播app污下载安装 彩色直播app下载免费 牛牛视频成版人 草榴直播成版人 直播盒子app下载免费 彩云直播成版人 享爱成版人 香蕉app下载免费 小喵直播app污下载安装 和欢视频app下载免费 红楼直播app污下载安装 夜猫视频app下载免费 野花视频app污下载安装 鸭脖视频app下载免费 荔枝视频app下载免费 JOJO直播app下载免费 秀色小抖音成版人 本色视频app下载免费 草莓app污下载安装 小公主直播app下载免费 年华直播app下载免费 梦露直播app污下载安装 尤蜜视频app下载免费 番茄直播app污下载安装 最污直播成版人 荔枝视频成版人 咪哒app下载免费 花友直播app下载免费 恋夜秀场app下载免费 JOJO直播app下载免费 茄子视频成版人 菠萝蜜成版人 乐购直播app污下载安装 快狐app下载免费 铁牛app下载免费 AVBOBO成版人 十里桃花直播app污下载安装 九尾狐直播成版人 猫咪软件app下载免费 荔枝视频成版人 成人快手app污下载安装 小狐仙视频app污下载安装 猫咪视频成版人 小公主直播成版人 彩云直播成版人 小草莓app下载免费 盘她s直播成版人 花姿直播成版人 91香蕉成版人 金鱼直播app污下载安装 豆奶抖音短视频app污下载安装 丝瓜视频污app下载免费 九尾狐视频成版人 IAVBOBO成版人 么么直播app污下载安装 泡芙成版人 春水堂视频成版人 樱桃直播成版人 蜜柚直播成版人 大小姐直播成版人 年华直播app污下载安装 麻豆视频app下载免费 快狐短视频app污下载安装 小花螺直播成版人 小怪兽直播成版人 麻豆传媒映画app污下载安装 红娘直播成版人 初恋直播app污下载安装 烟花巷直播app下载免费 泡芙短视频成版人 花姬app下载免费 朵朵直播app污下载安装 幸福宝成版人 心上人直播成版人 iavbobo成版人 黄瓜app下载免费 鸭脖视频成版人 名优馆app污下载安装 health2app下载免费 向日葵成版人 丝瓜视频成版人 荔枝app污下载安装 柚子直播成版人 Kitty直播成版人 秀色直播成版人 猫咪软件app污下载安装 AVBOBOapp污下载安装 草鱼app污下载安装 云雨直播app下载免费 快狐短视频app下载免费 望月app污下载安装 夜狼直播app污下载安装 番茄视频成版人 初恋直播成版人 性直播app污下载安装 成版人短视频app污下载安装 乐购直播app污下载安装 水果视频app下载免费 花粥直播app下载免费 秀儿直播成版人 名优馆app下载免费 荔枝视频app污下载安装 lutube成版人 草榴短视频app下载免费 光棍影院成版人 依恋直播app污下载安装 花椒直播app污下载安装 七仙女直播app下载免费 柚子直播app污下载安装 猫咪软件成版人 9uuapp下载免费 可乐视频app污下载安装 望月直播app污下载安装 小狐仙app污下载安装 番茄直播成版人 杏吧直播app下载免费 红杏视频成版人 朵朵直播app污下载安装 泡泡直播成版人 番茄直播成版人 丝瓜视频成版人 ML聚合直播成版人 红高粱直播成版人 猫咪软件app下载免费 f2富二代app下载免费 蚪音成版人 迷雾直播成版人 繁花直播app污下载安装 成版人短视频app下载免费 草榴短视频app污下载安装 笔芯直播app污下载安装 小奶狗视频app污下载安装 富二代成版人 妖妖直播app下载免费 恋夜秀场成版人 91直播app下载免费 初恋视频app污下载安装 小酒窝直播app下载免费 91香蕉成版人 小酒窝直播成版人 黄页荔枝成版人 望月app污下载安装 荔枝app污下载安装 月光直播app污下载安装 咪咪直播成版人 压寨直播成版人 6房间视频直播app污下载安装 小姐姐直播app污下载安装